You probably need to replace your old sump pump or you have just moved to a flood prone-area and are in need of a new one. However, you have no idea of which brand to go for given how many they are in the market.
Worry no more. This article is just for you. Many brands are known to manufacture sump pumps such as Zoeller, Wayne, Liberty and Superior pumps just to name a few. In this article, though, we shall look at a comparison between the Zoeller Sump Pump and the Wayne Sump Pump so that your decision-making process can be that easy.
A sump pump can be defined as a pump that is used to remove water that has accumulated in a water-collecting sump basin, which is found in the basements of most homes. Both pumps are used for this purpose, but they are definitely some differences between the two as shown.
Comparison between Zoeller Sump Pump and Wayne Sump Pump
Zoeller Sump Pump
This brand is known for making the highest performing sump pumps around. Having been in the industry for long, they have definitely earned their name as one of the most reputable brands for sump pump manufacturing.
The factors that make the Zoeller Sump Pump outperform the rest include:
- Pumping volume
- Clog resistance
- Reliability of the float valve
- Quality of the design and construction
- Durability
- Quiet operation
They may not be the cheapest sump pumps out there but it is important to note that cheap does not mean quality. The submersible pumps manufactured by Zoeller are completely factory tested underwater to ensure they are dependable. In addition, the testing is done so that you enjoy the problem-free operation for many years to come.
Advantages -
- The pumps are made of cast iron housings which perform a lot better than the cheaper sheet metal and plastic housings that cannot withstand the heat and vibrations.
- They are epoxy coated to make them corrosion resistant when in constant contact with water.
- Unlike ball-on-wire float switches, the Zoeller pumps have a linear motion mechanical float switch that does not jam easily.
- They can pump at high volumes from a range of 2600 gallons per hour to 3600 gallons per hour.
- To ensure quiet operation, they are fixed with rubber couplings on the discharge line.
- For clog resistance, the impeller has been designed to withstand solids of up to ½ inches in diameter.
Disadvantages -
- For some models such as the M53, the metal-air hole gets clogged with gunk or rust so you would need to drill a weep hole in the outlet pipe.
- The switches tend to be faulty and stick to the “ON” position so replacement of the switch from time to time is required. This can increase the overall maintenance cost.
Wayne Sump Pumps
When it comes to the Wayne Sump Pumps, on the other hand, they are the best priced, have a higher flow rate and are the most advanced like the WSM3300 model. Why you may ask? This is because they have a combination of a battery-powered backup pump and the entire system is computer controlled.
Sump pumps from this brand are also known to be heavy duty, which means they can handle any water volume found in your basement. They boast of having their pumps exceed an average life of 1 million pumping cycles during the cycle tests. Like the Zoeller pumps, they are also quiet during their performance.
Advantages -
- For durability and efficiency, they come with high-quality cast iron and stainless-steel structures.
- The sump pumps have a fast water discharge rate while the entire system can withstand the highest demanding levels of water.
- Models like the WSM3300 are computer controlled. This means that they monitor the main pump, the water level in the pit and the AC input so that you can tell if there is a problem and switch the backup on when required.
- They are made in such a way that they are easy to install without the need for any technical assistance.
- Unlike the Zoeller M53, models like the Wayne CDU1000 do not require a weep hole. Instead, it has a top suction design that reduces clogging and prevents an air lock condition.
Disadvantages -
- The floater mechanism can be difficult to work with because of the hook that it is attached to.
- The backup pump of some models can sit for a while before it starts working which can be frustrating at times.
- The float switch has to be changed every two years. This is a bummer considering most standard sump pumps have a float switch that lasts for longer.
Factors to Consider when Purchasing a Zoeller Sump Pump or Wayne Sump Pump
Powerful Motor
You should be keen on the horsepower of the sump pump because it determines the strength and power of the motor. In addition, it also gives you a crystal-clear indication of the lifespan of the motor and how efficient it is.
When you have a powerful motor, you can be sure that its performance is equally as top notch. If you live in an area experiencing high rainfall, a ½ horsepower unit would be best. On the other hand, if you have low-medium water intrusion, then purchasing a motor with a 1/3 horsepower should do the trick.
Materials and Installation
Number one important rule when purchasing a sump pump? Do not buy one made of plastic! Granted that they are cheaper, but remember, cheaper is not always quality. Go for sump pumps made of cast iron core because they are known to be non-corrosive, which means they can sustain you for longer. Also, they disperse heat to the water nearby to run efficiently.
Sump Pump Categories
Submersible sump pump vs pedestal sump pump. This is the dilemma am sure you are in but it all depends on preference and the one with most merits. In my opinion, it has got to be the submersible sump pump. Why though?
This is because it allows the sump pit to be covered thus promoting less noise and preventing falling of debris into the sump pit. An advantage of the lid is that it ensures moist air does not make its way to your home bringing other problems such as mold and the like.
Non-Clogging Sump Pumps
On the flip side, submersible sump pumps can be a terror when it comes to clogging. To reduce this, ensure the submersible sump pump purchased has a design that has a no-screen intake as a feature. This should be accompanied by an impeller that can withstand debris and other solids that are a ½ inch in diameter.
Conclusion
With the information provided, now you are in a better position to decide which brand to go for depending on your needs. Both brands are highly appreciated in the market and they also have their own merits and demerits. When purchasing this, make sure to consider this and the factors and you will be good to go.
Leave a Reply